Plaza Pastry Shop · Nutley, NJ

Your Neighborhood Bakery in Nutley

Family-owned, with breads, pastries and cakes for everyday moments and special occasions.

Plaza Pastry Shop's green and gold storefront sign on Franklin Avenue in Nutley
Chocolate, cream-frosted and decorated cakes in the Plaza Pastry Shop display case
Cakes photographed in our Nutley shop.

For Your Next Celebration

Let’s talk about your cake

A birthday, a gathering, or another occasion worth celebrating? Call us to discuss a custom cake and the options for your event.

Tell us your occasion, date and number of guests. We’ll discuss your request—please confirm lead time, pricing and pickup details with the shop before ordering.

Call About a Custom Cake

Around the Shop

Come on in

Find us on Franklin Avenue. Browse the cases, ask about today’s selection and bring a little Plaza home.

Your Neighborhood Stop

We’ll see you at Plaza Pastry Shop

39 Franklin Ave, Nutley, NJ 07110

Every day, 7am–6pm · Holiday hours may vary.

Call to order for pickup or ask about availability. No delivery.