From our Nutley bakery

Our Bakery Selection

From a loaf for the table to a cake for the occasion, get to know the selection at Plaza Pastry Shop.

A glimpse of our bakery, not a live menu. Photos illustrate our bakery selection. Daily availability and prices vary. Call to confirm your choices before ordering or visiting.

Loaves on Plaza Pastry Shop shelves with sourdough rye and sourdough labels
Sourdough loaves on our bakery shelves.

Breads

A loaf for the table, a slice for breakfast. Our photographed bread shelves include sourdough rye and sourdough loaves — examples of the selection, not a daily guarantee.

Rounded and oblong bakery rolls stacked on shelves at Plaza Pastry Shop
An assortment of rolls, alongside our larger loaves.

Rolls

Small breads with a place at any meal. Take a look at the assortment of rolls on our shelves, from rounded shapes to longer rolls.

A tray of rectangular Sicilian pizza slices topped with tomato sauce and browned cheeseRound personal pizzas topped with tomato sauce and browned cheese on a bakery trayGolden spinach croissants beside a Spinach Croissants sign at the bakery counterIndividual chicken and beef pot pies displayed in foil tins at Plaza Pastry ShopGolden beef empanadas on a tray beside a Beef Empanadas sign
Sicilian pizza, personal pizzas, spinach croissants, pot pies and empanadas.

Lunch

Make it a lunch visit with Sicilian pizza, personal pizzas, spinach croissants, pot pies, empanadas or sandwiches. Call to ask about today's selection and prices, then arrange your order for pickup.

Call about lunch
Stuffed breads labeled pepperoni, eggplant parm, spinach and cheese, Italian sausage and antipaste
Labeled stuffed bread varieties at the counter.

Stuffed Breads

Available Friday–Sunday. During the week, stuffed breads are made to order only—please call ahead to place your order. Savory fillings wrapped in bread. Varieties photographed at our counter include pepperoni, eggplant parm, spinach & cheese, Italian sausage and antipaste; the selection changes.

Cannoli, cream puffs, mini cheesecakes and assorted pastries in the Plaza display case
A look inside our pastry case.

Pastries

Something sweet for a quiet morning or a shared treat. Our display includes cannoli, cream puffs, mini cheesecakes and more, alongside cupcakes and decorated cookies. Photos show examples; call for today's selection.

Chocolate-topped and powdered donuts on bakery trays alongside other sweet pastries
Donuts and sweet bakes on our display trays.

Donuts

A sweet stop at the bakery. Our photographed trays show an assortment of donuts and other sweet bakes; ask about the styles in the shop today.

Chocolate and white layer cakes, cheesecakes and other sweets in Plaza Pastry Shop's display case
Cakes photographed in our shop's display case.

For your next occasion

Cakes

Our photographed cake case includes chocolate and white layer cakes, cheesecakes and other sweet bakes. These are examples of our selection, rather than a promise of what's in the case today.

A cake made for your celebration

Planning a custom cake? Call to discuss your date and occasion, the design and size you have in mind, pricing, the lead time needed and pickup arrangements.

Call About a Custom Cake

We'll see you in Nutley

Your next bakery stop

39 Franklin Ave, Nutley, NJ 07110
Open daily, 7am–6pm. Holiday hours may vary.
Orders are for pickup. No delivery.